Low Versus Higher Profile Wheels
by Lorne Goldman
For
the last two
decades, tyre sidewalls have been shrinking and rim diameters
growing. In other words, the cushion of air between the harder
parts of
your Morgan and the road has been reduced. This has affected the
handling and comfort of all cars, but none
more so than Morgan classic, with their simple vintage suspensions
and their use of a treasured traditional design made for other
tyres.
How did this all come about? Examining it gives clues to the
ever-increasing expenditure of newer Morgan owners with suspension and
steering "upgrades"..even as, for the most part, roads worldwide
have improved in the last few decades..
What a Racer Needs in Tyres
It is race cars that began this movement in the low profile
direction. But automobile racing is a specialized sport, done
on specialized surfaces, a
specialized environment, using specialized cars specifically
altered and/or designed for this game and venue. With few
exceptions,
racing surfaces are made and maintained to a much higher and
consistent standard than a road going vehicle encounters. As well,
comfort is a much
lower priority in sport than it is in travel.These
elements mitigate the need for race track suspension. The primary
goal of racing
is to win and all other considerations, such as safe and enjoyable
transport are secondary..even forced upon participants by
rules. Lastly, the support infrastructure
is meters
away at all times. In these odd circumstances, the few pros of low
profile tyres make
sense.
But to emulate something that is functional in another environment
only makes no sense...especially when the car that adopts them is not
redesigned to accommodate them. I am reminded of the first space-age
days of the 1950/60s. The exitement, then about rockets more than race
cars, spawned a trend to
exaggerated car fins, though they added weight,
altered aerodynamics, and very dangerously added to impact risks
without providing
any compensatory functional benefit. Happily, the Factory
avoid these fins, even at the peak of the rage for them. I imagine it
was less sensitive to buyer tastes in those days.
Alleged Pros to low profile tyres
Improved steering response
Higher top end speeds and mileage from lower rolling resistance
Improved sidewall stability under braking
Room for bigger brakes
Less camber distortion when cornering.
I used the word "alleged" to wan the reader that there are articles
that refute many of these factors. But the needs of a road driving
person are far more complex than that
of racer. Comfort..the absorption of road anomalies that
racing compeitors do not need. As well, a road driver meets a far
wider variety of road surfaces than a racer ever will, without the
nearby support or skills the racer has at his/her call.
Cons to low profile tyres
Less of a progressive breakaway (tyres break away more suddenly
More susceptable to sidewall damage and tyre failure
Added unsprung weight
More susceptable to tram tracking
Harsher less confortable ride
More critical to tyre pressures
More road noise
More unsprung weight. In fact, both the wheel and the tyre weight theoretically increases. I have not checked this out, but a dealer can do so for us.
Anyone who imagines even 5mm+ less air does not make a NOTICEABLE difference is dead wrong. And Morgans have lost 5 times that or 25mm of air cushion between rim and ground! No wonder new car owners are fixated on aftermarket "upgrades".
WATCHPOINT:
Easy
to confirm if there is a Morgan dealer or friend around
with another
compatible (suspension and tyres) Morgan with a different rim diameter.
Simply
take your car on a mildly anomalied road for a short test drive.
Then
swap wheels and test the different combol on the same
drive. Which was better? Frankly, you will understand all you need to
know after a few meters, not kilometers. |
So why
did the automobile market move in this direction? Aesthetics and a lack of understanding
of the consumer is the only answer.
But why did Morgan followed in this direction? They have not compensated forthe loss of air with a redesign of the car. (Aside from ever wider wing widths, the infamous fetish of Charles Morgan, the functional effects of which require another article)
whether by instinct or wisdom, the company has steadfastly refused
to alter the perceived design dynamics which have carried the car 'til
this point from the mid-1930s. Yet, illogically, Morgan HAS
moved from 14 inch to as much as 17 inch rims with
its most powerful Classic models while keeping the same overall
diameter..putting themselves between a rock (the needed traditional
design) and a hard place (modern customer tastes and the road).
I have attempted to offer a visual of
the changes in the adjacent diagram. (Those who argue with my iffy
artistry need only precisely compare its tyre bands/ side walls and rims diamters to
confirm.) Yet during most of this journey, (saving the last example which has a wholly non-Classic chassis, braking and suspension),
the overall wheel/tyre diameter has not changed and neother has the
design of the car, its steering or its suspension been altered to meet
the challenges. Merely the ratio
of air to metaI is altered. Curiously. the recommended factory
tyre pressure remained the same throughout these diameters. Admittedly,
increasing the pressures would better protect the rims, at an
additional risk to the driver safety and comfort.
What does it mean? Automobile wheel air to metal ratios are not (yet) a
subject of legislation. And
with former skills levels and autombile understanding declining in the
community, the
importance of aesthetics to sales has increased..
The complaints and warnings on the internet about low profile tyres on
other more knowledgeable forums is growing.
Examples are given often. Questions why earlier models
of many marques were
more comfortabl are asked more often. A "google" reveals scores of such
complaints. In fact, this article was spawned by them. I merely
recognized their issue in the complaints I receive on the GoMoG Help
Line. It is easier to make a Morgan with smaller rims handle well
and be comfortable than it is with the newer models.
Sizing
When selecting a wheel/tyre combo with any existing car you have, you should always select the size
with the closest to factory overall wheel/tyre diameter, regardless of
the rim size. You can use a calculator like this one
to calculate the difference in overall diameter from your stock wheel
to the new one. I have found that staying within .8% of the original is good. I like to stay with 0.3% or less
whenever possible. For
Morgan Classic owners, this calculation is made easy by simply looking
to earlier years with their smaller rims and adopting their tyres specs
as well.
The tyre size you use with whatever wheel diameter you pick can be
juggled with a little bit to achieve the right overall diameter.
Sidewall & Overall Size Considerations
With wheel diameter increases come a decrease in sidewall size in
order to maintain the same overall tyre+wheel combo size. It's important
to stay as close to the stock tyre+wheel combo size as the overall
wheel size affects gearing.
Smaller wheels
improve acceleration at the expense of top end, and taller wheels
decrease acceleration while theoretically increasing top speed (though
in practice top speed is limited by power and drag long before tyre
size..so for most cars, and definitely for Morgans, this factor is
irrelevant. Increasing tyre size usually also hurts top end
acceleration and top speed as it decreases the engine's ability to
overcome the air drag holding the car back).
In any case, making the overall wheel/tyre combo taller or shorter
will again affect suspension geometry. I don't advise this, especially for a road car. You can change it a small amount
without any real adverse effects but try to stay as close as possible
when choosing a new combined size.
Additionally,
the big "gotcha" with sidewall size is that the smaller the sidewall,
the less protection your probably expensive rims will have from the
inevitable pothole or road debris. If you keep the same wheels with
lower profile tyres, the only route to more protection for your rims is
increased pressure, which will prejudice safety, handling and comfortt,
thusly prioritising the rims over yourself.
Small sidewalls are very stiff, great for cornering "feel" but
terrible for ride quality and straight line stopping and acceleration
(more on that later). Stiffer sidewalls do not give any additional grip.
However, as a result of an increase in wheel diameter, the
weight distribution of the wheel+tyre combo worsens - as the heaviest part
(the tyre) is now further away from the center of the wheel - a no-no as it robs precious power from getting
to the road. Many guys spend so much time focusing on the wheel weight
but never even think about thedistribution of the tyre weight and its effect on the entire weight
distribution of the wheel.
WATCHPOINT: Never make the
mistake of choosing a tyre by its weight. Usually a tyre's weight is
directly proportional to how much reinforcement is inside the tyre.
Cheap tyres are often lightweight, but only because the manufacturer saved on
the sidewall reinforcement. And cheaper tyre go out
of round (square) because they are so cheaply made inside. Choose tyres based on
tread and compound - never by weight. DO consider the weight of the tyre
when picking the size of your wheel, however. Getting confused yet? |
Larger
sidewalls allow better ride quality, better straight line launch,
braking and do not necessarily decrease grip though they do work to
prevent a sudden (aka losing it!) rather than gradual break from the
road. But they may make the car handle less precisely. In other words,
the sidewall flexes so the steering response will be slower and you get
a lot more "roll" in the bends. Too big of a sidewall can cause
excessive tyre temperatures due to a lot of flexing about and possible
failure in race conditions so it still is ideal to keep relatively low
profile sidewalls on performance applications as we mentioned earlier.
As mentioned, Morgans successfully used 14 and 15" rims for decades.
Still do.
You will notice that drag racing slicks always have very tall
sidewalls. You never see low profile drag slicks. This is because when
a drag car launches, the tyre actually deforms and ripples up to create
an even fatter patch of rubber on the ground and to generate 'bite'
into the ground. The smaller the sidewall you use, the more likely you
will spin your tyres off the line. Taller sidewall tyres can generally
bite harder both under braking and acceleration. Yet as modern Morgans
become more powerful, their sidewalls are shrinking. So
again, this doesn't make sense.
Choices
Yes. These
market factors have reduced the neighborhood availability of 14/15 inch
tyres. But Morgan Classics are a vintage design and the offerings from
vintage tyre suppliers have increased, rather than diminished. It
makes no sense to own a Morgan unless you treat it right.
COMMENT:
Hi Lorne,
Finally someone speaking the truth about low profile tires, especially where a Morgan is concerned.
My thoughts 100%.
Like you, get tired of hearing how bad Morgan suspension is. Or hearing how things break due to lack
of suspension when the going gets tough. I can imagine nothing worse than low profile tires.
Thanks for your articles on gomog.
Cheers
Win
The Problem With Large Wheels by David Finlay for MSN February 19, 2018
At a press event several years ago I had a pleasant chat with the UK
marketing director of a certain car company. Despite his title, he was
German, and he expressed amazement at the British enthusiasm for
choosing large wheels and low-profile tyres from the options list. This
was much less common in his home country, where, he told me, wheel
sizes are on average at least an inch smaller than they are here.
Not
that he was complaining about it. There’s a lot of profit in persuading
people to pick the large-wheel option. It usually adds several hundred
pounds to the price, in some cases a few thousand, and you can bet your
life that the manufacturers are paying the wheel and tyre makers only a
small fraction of that.
The usual reason for upgrading to larger wheels is that they look
better than small ones. If that appeals to you, and you’re prepared to
spend money on achieving it, Fair enough. But there are a few
problems. For a start, there’s a greater risk of damaging a larger wheel
against a kerb. They’re also more expensive to replace. Most of all,
they frequently make the car much less pleasant to drive.
This
isn’t always true. Back in 1997, Subaru sold a car called the Impreza
Sport. The only technical difference between the Sport and the GL was
that the Sport’s wheels were one inch larger. You might not think this would make much difference, but it did. The
GL was a pleasant car to drive. The Sport was glorious. That small
change in wheel size sharpened up the handling almost unbelievably. More
commonly, though, the optional wheels and tyres make little difference
to the handling and have a devastating effect on the ride quality.
It’s
not the wheels themselves that cause this. It’s the fact that you have
to fit lower-profile tyres to them so that the circumference remains the
same. If you didn’t, there would be space issues and the gearing would
go to pot. Lower-profile tyres have smaller sidewalls (the sidewall being the
part of the tyre you can see around the wheel when you’re looking at it
side-on). Since there is less rubber, it can’t be deformed as easily, so
shocks which would otherwise be absorbed by it are passed through to
the suspension instead. Suspension is set up to deal with a
particular wheel/tyre size. (As Morgan never changed their suspension when they changed wheel size), the suspension is no
longer able to cope as well as it did before. It does not damp the
shocks coming from the road as effectively, so those shocks are
transferred to the rest of the car and, ultimately, to you.
This
is noticeable in all cars, but in some more than others. The
first-generation Audi Q5 and its close relative, the Porsche Macan, were
set up on the assumption that they would be fitted with 18-inch wheels,
and were very comfortable when that happened. In each case, fitting
20-inch wheels instead was a disaster. An obvious contrast was apparent within the Porsche range. By the
time the Macan was launched, all 911s came with 20-inch wheels as
standard, and their suspension were set up accordingly. It may seem
strange that a company could make a sports car with a more comfortable
ride than an SUV, but that’s what Porsche did.
Like the 911, the
current-generation Renault Scenic and Grand Scenic MPVs have 20-inch
wheels too. Also like the 911, they were designed from the start to run
on them. The shocks transferred through the low-profile tyres are
adequately absorbed by the suspension, and the occupants do not suffer.
There’s
little sign that other mainstream manufacturers will follow Renault’s
example, but perhaps some day they will. Until then, I’ll always choose
the smallest wheels available. My car may not look as good as one whose
owner went for the large-wheel option, but it will be far more
comfortable to drive.
WIDE VERSUS NARROW TYRES
Newer owners are not going to like the following comments. When choosing tires for your vehicle, you might believe that picking
the widest tire is best. However, that may not be the case, especially with Morgans.
There are advantages and disadvantages to both wide and narrow tyres.
When determining which kind is best for your vehicle, it’s important to
think about what you want out of the tire and also about your car
itself.
CONSIDERATIONS
Car weight — For some vehicles, buying a
wider tire is not realistic because the weight of the vehicle will put
insufficient pressure on the tire. If you were to mount a wide
tire on a car that was too light, you run the risk of loosing
traction and slowing the car. If you mount tires that are too wide on a
vehicle that is very light, you will experience wheelspin, which can
damage other internal systems in your car. So make sure you purchase the
appropriate tires based on the weight of your vehicle. Morgans are close to the the lightest cars in the world.
Traction — Having more pressure per square inch or a
wider contact area are two options for creating greater traction for
your car’s tires. With wide tires, you have a broader contact area,
while skinny tires create more pressure per square cm. There’s no way
you can have both options, so it’s best to find a balance based on what
kind of roads you will be driving on and other conditions that will
affect your vehicle. Always tune and set up your Morgan for the roads you enjoy the most.
Wet condition driving — Wide tires are better for
driving in wet weather since they have sipes, which help to trap and
remove water from the contact surface. Narrow tires have sipes as well,
but since they have a smaller surface area, they have less of them. One
positive aspect of narrow tires in the rain is that when going through
puddles, the higher contact pressure moves water out of the way.
However, tyree technology has moved ahead. You can buy narrow tyres that give amazing control on wet roads and puddles.
Dry road racing — If you’re mostly going to drive
on streets with dry asphalt, you should consider going with wide tires. For
this type of road material, the increased surface area provides better
traction than having more pressure at a sacrifice to speed..
Fuel consumption — The less friction your vehicle
produces, the lower your steering effort, which also means less fuel
consumption. Wide tires provide for more friction, making your vehicle
consume more fuel, whereas narrow tires cause your car to consume less
fuel because they have lower amounts of friction.
Comfort - Narrower tyres are more comfortable and make less noise.
Stopping - Wider tyres stop faster.
These features must be carefully studied for Morgan owners
more than most other vehicle owners considering how unusual Morgans
are. Morgans are extremely agile and light cars. If you wish larger,
fat tyres, buy another sports car. Aesthetics are only as good as long
as they affect performance and handling. Wide tyres on Morgan's kill a
LOT of the fun. One of the tragedies of the new Morgans (Aeros, CRX) is
that they sacrifice performance and spped by ignoring the reality of
these cars and have fit them with much wider tyres as today's owners
choose looks over reality.